End of the road for 3-wheelers in India?, Auto News, ET Auto

By Avik Chattopadhyay

Quantities nowadays are the consequence of what was carried out yesterday. And they need to have not be the harbinger of what will transpire tomorrow. But if your quantities persist while all those of others’ jump it calls for a pause and shut appear. The pandemic has strike the complete automobile industry really hard. Nevertheless, due to the fact September there have been signs of revival, in particular by passenger cars and trucks and UVs. The quantities present that the section that proceeds to be in doldrums is that of the 3-wheeler.

What could be the cause for the disappointing performance of all the makes? Has the 3-wheeler section dropped its relevance, or is it due to the fact of a function improve or new options?

The quantities

The April to Oct 2020 domestic wholesale quantities of 3-wheelers present seventy eight% fall more than 2019. Even exports fell by 35%.

Though the drastic decrease of passenger provider 3-wheelers can be defined by the strike public transport has taken in these months, the fall in merchandise provider 3-wheelers is a make any difference of issue. A regional auto-rickshaw fleet may not expand owing to lowered client need. Though the e-commerce and shipping expert services are viewing a spike owing to altered acquiring behaviour, why do the ubiquitous shipping motor vehicles not see a revival in quantities?

The retail quantities far more or a lot less mirror the wholesale in terms of drops more than 2019-twenty. It was not these a great yr for the classification as info shows vis-à-vis 2018-19.


The critical function of the 3-wheelers

Just like the commuter two-wheeler and entry-amount motor vehicle, the a few-wheeler is one particular of the essential contributors to democratising mobility in any economic system. It has typically been the “last mile” mobility option for transporting people and merchandise.

Its compact dimensions, small turning radius, the adaptability of software and frugal operating expenses manufactured the 3W well known for both of those the owners and the buyers. It has provided work and nurtured micro-enterprises.

When e-commerce logistics and multi-modal mobility are the buzzwords, the 3-wheelers should really see a bull-run, and any blip in income can only be non permanent. With better penetration of all expert services, from apparel to medications, there should really by no means be a boring minute for this section.

And if the 3-wheeler section encounters one particular of its dullest times while its function continues to be intact, has anyone else come and upset its applecart [no pun supposed]?

The alternatives…

Let us study two offerings from Mahindra in the “Small Commercial Vehicle” house – the 3-wheeled Alfa Additionally and the four-wheeled Jeeto S6-sixteen.

Though Jeeto expenses far more than double the Alfa, the issue I am elevating in this article is that the four-wheeled micro CVs are having into the 3-wheelers. The four-wheeled choices offer better operational stability, payloads and everyday living. In excess of the lifecycle of the vehicle, it pays back for its greater sticker price. Consider the Tata Ace Zip as a different viable selection at a far more aggressive price.

For passenger carriers choices like Bajaj Adorable are accessible. The manufacturer has opened up a new section of “quadricycle” – in essence a 3-wheeler with a 4th wheel! Tata Motors has an appealing product termed Magic Iris.

Bajaj Adorable

For any commuter making use of a Bajaj RE or TVS King, the closed Adorable or Iris is a far better selection unless of course one particular wants to vacation in an overloaded 3-wheeler. The closed vehicle development also lets for the incorporation of cleanliness protocol which may develop into standard in the days to come. Though this classification is however to get traction, the different that is having the wind out of the passenger provider 3-wheeler is the electrical auto-rickshaw. Not incorporated in the SIAM and FADA info releases, one particular does not have any plan of how this new mode of previous-mile mobility has mushroomed all close to us, earning it virtually like a cottage industry, with scant basic safety specifications in procedure. It has terribly impacted 3-wheeler income with the pandemic driving a massive nail into it.

The verdict

The function performed by the 3-wheeler in previous-mile mobility is unquestioned. Just that there are options on possibly finish of the spectrum are making use of pressure and questioning its incredibly raison d’etre.

It is up to day in the market with eco-friendly powertrains and emission regulate with CNG and electrical versions. Its mild development previously can make it vitality economical and frugal.

The Achilles heel is basic safety. Offered the function the vehicle performs in the intra and inter-metropolis transport, its frontal and side-effect specifications need to have to be at par with that of a four-wheeler like an Alto or i10. Much more so, as the vehicle is not lined and does not offer any side security. The electrical kinds are in essence coffins on skateboards, with just tubes bolted on to a ground. It is a disgrace that they are permitted to ply on our roadways below the nose of CMVR, certainly with vested pursuits at perform.

At the time the proposed Bharat New Car or truck Safety Assessment Programme will come into procedure, it ought to assure no compromise on this front. It seems inconceivable that the a few-wheeler will pass the crash test necessities, presented its inherent instability and lack of security.

That is why Bajaj cleverly developed the RE into the Adorable and is pushing the new classification of the quadricycle. Though the automakers see it as a danger to the entry-amount passenger motor vehicle, it is basically a actual danger to the a few-wheeler. The current a few-wheeler makers need to have to wake up to the simple fact that unsafe motor vehicles can not be dished out any far more, below no matter what pretext of price tag, entry or adoption. They can perform in direction of developing the quadricycle section into a significant one particular.

Our well known 3-wheeler was anyway dealing with a downturn more than the previous one particular yr. The pandemic has dealt it a well timed system blow. This is the possibility for it to be phased out, by regulation. It shall usually stay etched in our memory but need to have not stay on the roadways.

(The creator is co-creator of Expereal India. Also, he is former head of internet marketing, product arranging and PR at Volkswagen India.)

(DISCLAIMER: The views expressed are exclusively of the authors and ETAuto.com does not essentially subscribe to it. ETAuto.com shall not be accountable for any problems caused to any particular person/organisation right or indirectly.)